What If Job Seekers Are Already Doing Everything Right?

I came across a post recently that made me stop and think. It was written by someone who had been looking for work for an extended period and they were expressing frustration with the advice they kept seeing online. You know the kind of advice: tailor your CV, make sure it is ATS-friendly, optimise your LinkedIn profile, network more and follow up after applying.

Their point was not that this advice was wrong. In fact, they openly acknowledged that much of it was helpful. What frustrated them was the assumption sitting behind it. After months of searching, countless applications, multiple revisions of their CV and endless hours spent trying to improve their chances, hearing the same advice over and over again felt exhausting.

If I'm honest, it stopped me in my tracks because I realised I have given some of that advice myself. Not because it isn't important. A strong CV, an active LinkedIn profile and a well-developed network can absolutely improve a person's chances of success. However, when someone has been looking for work for six months, nine months or even longer, repeatedly hearing the same advice can feel frustrating and, at times, dismissive.

Being told to "tailor your CV" can start to feel a little like telling someone running a marathon to remember to tie their shoelaces. It's not bad advice, but there is a fair chance they have already done it. In fact, they've probably done it multiple times.

The more I thought about it, the more I realised that much of the career advice we share assumes that if someone is not getting results, there must be something they are not doing. Perhaps their CV needs work. Perhaps they need to improve their interview skills. Perhaps they need to network more effectively. Sometimes those things are absolutely true, but not always.

I have spoken with people who have done everything they reasonably can. They have sought professional support, updated their LinkedIn profiles, attended networking events, rewritten their CVs, practised interview techniques and applied thoughtfully for roles that genuinely align with their skills and experience. These are not people sitting back and waiting for opportunities to appear. They are putting in the effort and often far more effort than others realise.

Yet many continue to find the process incredibly challenging. One of the risks of career advice is that it can unintentionally create the impression that every outcome sits within the job seeker's control. If you're not getting interviews, your CV must be wrong. If you're not getting offers, your interview skills must need work. If you're not finding opportunities, perhaps you're not networking enough.

The reality is that today's job market is more complex than that. Roles can attract hundreds of applicants. Hiring processes are often longer than they once were. Internal candidates are increasingly common. Organisations pause recruitment, change priorities and adjust budgets. Sometimes highly capable people miss out simply because another candidate happened to have a very specific piece of experience that aligned with what the organisation needed at that moment in time.

That does not mean there is nothing people can do to improve their chances. There almost always are things that can strengthen an application or improve an interview performance. However, we should be careful about assuming that a lack of results automatically reflects a lack of effort, capability or preparation.

Perhaps what many job seekers need right now is not another list of tips. Perhaps they need acknowledgement that they are already working incredibly hard in a market that has become more competitive, more complex and often less predictable than it was a decade ago.

If you're reading this while navigating a difficult job search, there is something else worth remembering. The process has a way of distorting how we see ourselves. The longer it goes on, the easier it becomes to measure your value by the number of interviews you secure, the responses you receive or the offers that don't eventuate. Yet none of those things tell the full story.

A delayed response does not erase years of experience. A rejection does not diminish the contribution you've made throughout your career. An uncertain market does not change the skills, knowledge and strengths you bring to the table. The job market may be evaluating your application, but it is not defining your worth. That distinction can be difficult to hold onto during a prolonged search, but it is one worth protecting.

If there is one thing I have learned from speaking with job seekers, it is that many are already doing the things career professionals recommend. The challenge is that a strong CV, a polished LinkedIn profile and a tailored application are only part of the picture. Career success is rarely determined by a single factor. Sometimes the issue is positioning. Sometimes it is confidence. Sometimes it is career direction and sometimes it is simply a difficult market.

What many people need is not another reminder to update their CV, but encouragement to keep going, confidence in the value they bring and reassurance that struggling to find work in a difficult market is not the same thing as failing. Sometimes the most helpful thing we can do is stop assuming people are not trying hard enough and start recognising just how much effort they are already putting in. 

So, this message is to you, Job Seeker.

If you've been putting in the effort, rewriting your CV, tailoring applications, networking, preparing for interviews and wondering what more you could possibly be doing, please don't let a difficult market convince you that you have nothing to offer. Keep going. The right opportunity may take longer to find than any of us would like, but your worth is not determined by how quickly an employer recognises your value.

---

From Sonja

One of the things I've learned through my work is that career challenges are rarely as straightforward as they first appear. Sometimes the issue is a CV, sometimes it's confidence, sometimes it's career direction and sometimes it's simply a difficult market.

Whatever stage of the journey you're navigating, I hope this article served as a reminder that a lack of results is not always a reflection of a lack of effort.

Sonja Passmore

Career Strategist & Founder | Pick a Path